Document Type : Research Article
Authors
Crop and Horticultural Science Research Department, Isfahan Agricultural and NaturalResources Research and Education Center, AREEO, Isfahan, Iran
Abstract
Introduction
The industrialization of agriculture has led to more uniform agricultural systems and reduced diversity in terms of plant species grown and richness. Crop yields in monocultures have increased significantly over the last five decades mainly through the substantial application of synthetic inputs. These increased yields are associated with several challenges such as heightened soil erosion, excessive nutrient input resulting in eutrophication and groundwater pollution, and a substantial decline in biodiversity due to the extensive application of pesticides and herbicides. Therefore, for sustainable food production, the efficiency of agroecosystems needs to be enhanced. Crop diversification has been suggested as one critical strategy. Crop diversification options include crop rotation, intercropping, and cover cropping. Cultivation of two or more crop species concurrently as they coexist for a significant part of the crop cycle is known as intercropping. Intercropping research has been mainly focused on cereals and legumes intercropping in tropical and subtropical regions and less attention has been given to research on intercropping of vegetable crops. Publications around intercropping of onion and lettuce in Iran are scarce. Thus, this research was conducted to evaluate competition indices in onion and lettuce intercropping.
Materials and Methods
This research was conducted from 2021 to 2023 in the Research Farm of Behbahan AgriculturalResearch Station. The experiment was set up in randomized complete block design with 14 treatments and three replications. The treatments included moncultures of onion and lettuce, three planting patterns of intercropping, 75% onion and 25% lettuce, 50% onion and 50% lettuce as well as 25% onion and 75% lettuce, in four planting densities (distance between onion plants in row were 5 and 7 cm and between lettuce plants were 20 and 30 cm). Seeds of onion and lettuce were sown in nursery simultaneously in mid-October. Before planting, soil in experimental plots was plowed and nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium fertilizers were applied based on results of soil analysis and recommendation of Soil and Water Institute of Iran. All plots received the equivalent of 46 kg P ha-1 as triple super phosphate and 100 kg K ha-1 in form of potassium sulfate during soil preparation. Nitrogen wasapplied at a rate of 120 and 130 kg N ha-1 as urea for onion and lettuce, respectively. Seedlings of onion and lettuce were transplanted in late November and late December, respectively. Lettuce was harvested in early March and onion harvested in mid-May. After harvesting land equivalent ratio, aggressivity, relative crowding coefficient, competition ratio and actual yield loss indices were calculated. Data gathered for different traits in 2 years were combined and subjected to a combined analysis of variances using SPSS v.26 Software. Significant differences among treatments means were determined at 0.05 probability level using Duncan's test.
Results and Discussion
Onion and lettuce yield were higher in monocultures in comparison to intercrop treatments. The evaluation of yield in all treatments in intraction effect of year and treatment showed the highest yield belong to planting patteren of 50% onion and 50% lettuce, with a spacing of 5 cm between onion plants and 20 cm between lettuce plants in the second year of the experiment. However the increase of yield in this treatment was not significant as compared with planting patteren of 75% onion + 25% lettuce (in all planting densities) and planting patteren of 50% onion + 50% lettuce (in all planting densities, except for a spacing of 5 cm between onion plants and 20 cm between lettuce plants in the first year as well as planting patteren of 25% onion + 75% lettuce in two planting densities (a spacing of 7 cm between onion plants and 20 cm between lettuce plants and a spacing of 5 cm between onion plants and 20 cm between lettuce plants) in the second year. The land equvalent ratio and relative crowding coefficient indices were higher than unity in all intrercrop treatments (in both two years of experiment) that confirming yield advantage of intercropping. The calculation of partial value of aggressivity, relative crowding coefficient, competition ratio and actual yield loss indices indicated in almost all treatments, due to broader and more horizontal leaves of lettuce ad slow growth habit of onion, lettuce was more comprtitive than onion.
Conclusion
The results suggested that the planting patteren of 50% onion and 50% lettuce with a spacing of 5 cm between onion plants and 20 cm between lettuce plants that ranked in superior group in terms of yield and land equivalent ratio in both two years of experiment can be recommended to farmers. The calculation of competition indices indicated in almost all treatments lettuce was more comprtitive than onion.
Keywords
Subjects